OB1 wrote:I am both amazed and appalled by some of the knee-jerk comments about Triumph in this thread. Some who have slagged Triumph off for their reaction to the OP's warranty claim and others who have suggested that Triumph "should fail" for their lack of action. Again I will say that they are being found guilty via social media. Apart from Steve, I don't think that anyone on here knows the full story about how or why the frame cracked and such defamatory comments are what I would expect from a second rate tabloid.
Contrast the comments here to those that have been posted on ADVRider in a thread that seems to have been started by someone else:
Triumph CEO says 800XC for "light offroad use". The main consensus in that thread surprised me as most of the comments come from Americans who, as we all know, will sue at the drop of a hat! The majority of comments on there seem to be along the lines of "you chose to ride your bike in a certain manner, dropped it several times and then asked Triumph to replace the frame". It seems as though they have more information than has been provided here:
Breakages/Repairs
Chain guard broke and fell off, in Patagonia due to excessive side wind.
Main frame down tubes fractured below where it meets the rear sub frame? Spot welded in Colombia now waiting on reply from Triumph UK regarding replacement or repair?
Punctures: 1 front
Left wing mirror replaced.
Left front indicator replaced.
Left pannier hammered back into shape.
Front wheel rim dented on left side after hitting massive pothole, rim hammered back into shape.
Crash bars pulled back out from engine casing.
Fog lamp mounting point on main light cluster repaired with steel epoxy.
Two top yoke bolts replaced after they went missing, fell out somewhere?
Chain guide broke repaired with cable ties.
Right hand plastic tank gaurd/cowling shattered after fall due to extreme cold weather.
Front mudguard mounting points broken due to falling of stand when getting new tyres fitted.
Both fog lamps lenses cracked due to falls.
Crashes and falls
On road: 1, around 60mph both me and bike escaped with no damage after sliding on left side to a halt on gravel verge.
On gravel: 1, bike; twisted bars, smashed wing mirror, broken indicator, engine crash bars pushed right into engine and left pannier bent and bashed. Me broken ribs and bruised arm and leg left side.
Slow speed falls in the sand: 3 no damages.
Bike blown over by wind in Patagonia: 4 no damages.
Dropped bike: 3
Falls in snow and ice: 4
When you read all of this, would you still expect Triumph, or any other motorcycle manufacturer, to replace your frame?
OB1,
As you rightly point out no one knows (not even Triumph, as they said it was due to overloading?) how the frame cracked. I have been riding long enough (road, motocross, enduro) and crashed enough bikes over the years to have a good idea what breaks them and what doesn't. At no time did I directly impact any other object or vehicle and in my opinion the fractures were not caused by me falling off, but I'm no expert that's just my honest opinion.
As you have also pointed out I listed all my crashes and falls on my blog the majority of which happened after the fractures appeared. My trip report was a true account of my adventure so as to give anyone else planning such a trip a good idea of what to expect, as it's not all plain sailing. And as I said previously anyone going on a similar trip will fall off and they will expect their bike to cope with the rigours of overland travel, which is a bit different to green lane-ing in the UK!